Most Disappointing Teams in NBA Finals History: 1995 Orlando Magic
The 1995 Orlando Magic Had Shaq, Penny and the East’s Best Record. Then Houston Swept Them.
By June 1995, the Orlando Magic had arrived years ahead of schedule. Six seasons after their first game, they had Shaquille O’Neal and Penny Hardaway, both 23, a 57-win season, the East’s top seed and a path to the Finals that ran through Boston, Michael Jordan’s Bulls and a seven-game war with Indiana.
Houston ended it in four games. The defending champions, seeded sixth in the West, won Game 1 in Orlando after the Magic led by three with seconds left, and Orlando never won a game in the series. The East’s best team getting swept by a sixth seed was not how most people expected the Finals to go.
Twenty-one years later, here’s how the dream run hit the wall, from Orlando’s bench.
Orlando’s Young Core Takes Over
Nobody in the league scored like the 1994-95 Magic. They averaged 110.9 points a game, first among 27 teams, and their 115.1 offensive rating also ranked first. Hardaway, Nick Anderson, Dennis Scott, Horace Grant and O’Neal could punish a defense from anywhere, and at the Orlando Arena they lost twice all season.
O’Neal was the force at the center of it: 29.3 points, 11.4 rebounds and 2.4 blocks on .583 shooting. Hardaway made the whole thing move, posting 20.9 points, 7.2 assists and 1.7 steals. Anderson, the first draft pick in franchise history, added 15.8 points, and Scott spaced the floor as a three-point specialist, scoring 12.9.
Brian Hill’s 1993-94 team had won 50 games and lost in the first round of the franchise’s first playoff trip. A year later, Orlando shook off a 2-2 start with a nine-game winning streak, hit the All-Star break at 37-10 and held on for the Atlantic Division title despite dropping seven of its last eleven.
Successfully Recruiting Horace Grant
That first-round exit told Orlando what it was missing. Horace Grant had it. The 6-foot-10 power forward, drafted 10th overall by Chicago in 1987 out of Clemson, had won three straight titles with the Bulls from 1991 to 1993. He chose Orlando for a reported $2.1 million, less than some other offers. Brian Shaw signed too, as a second ball handler.
Grant fit right in beside O’Neal. In 74 games he averaged 12.8 points, 9.7 rebounds, 2.3 assists, 1.0 steals and 1.2 blocks in 36.4 minutes, the same rebounding and defense he brought to Chicago. On a roster full of rising stars, he was the one who already knew what June felt like.
His signature moment came against his old team. In the conference semifinals, the Magic shot 31 percent in the first half of one game against the Bulls. Grant pulled them through with 24 points on 10-of-13 shooting and 11 rebounds, and Orlando took a 3-2 series lead.
Clearing the East to Reach Houston
Boston fell 3-1 in the first round. Chicago went down in six. Across those two series, the Magic lost only three times. Shaw averaged 6.6 points in 16.9 minutes over the full playoff run, and Anthony Bowie, Jeff Turner and Donald Royal rounded out a rotation built around the starters.
Indiana was a different fight. The conference finals went seven games, and the home team won every one of them. Orlando owned home court and made it count, routing the Pacers 105-81 in Game 7. A franchise that won 18 games in its first season, 1989-90, was four wins from a title.
Houston had been there before. The Rockets went just 47-35 in the regular season, then beat Utah, Phoenix and San Antonio, with Hakeem Olajuwon averaging 35.3 points against the Spurs. Clyde Drexler had arrived from Portland at midseason. Before the series, nearly every conversation came back to the centers: O’Neal against Olajuwon, the reigning Finals MVP.
Losing the 1995 NBA Finals
Once they arrived on the big stage, it all fell apart for the Orlando Magic.
The Infamous Four Missed Free Throws
Game 1, June 7, Orlando Arena, 16,010 in the seats. The Magic jumped on the champions, winning the first quarter 30-19 and pushing the lead to 20. Houston stormed ahead with a 37-19 third quarter. Orlando answered with a 30-23 fourth, and with 8.5 seconds left in regulation, the Magic led 110-107.
Robert Horry fouled Nick Anderson, a 70.4 percent free-throw shooter that season. Anderson missed the first. Then the second. He grabbed his own rebound, drew a foul from Drexler with under eight seconds left and went back to the line. He missed both again. Houston rebounded, called timeout, and Kenny Smith drilled a three with 1.6 seconds to go. Overtime.
Houston took overtime 10-8. The final points came with 0.3 seconds left, when Olajuwon tipped in a missed Drexler finger roll to win it 120-118. Hardaway and O’Neal had 26 points apiece. Olajuwon had 31 points, 7 assists and 4 blocks in all 48 minutes.
Getting Dominated by Houston’s Bench
Two nights later, back before 16,010 in Orlando, the Magic needed to answer. Houston answered first. The Rockets won the first quarter 28-19 and the second 35-22, and they went to halftime up 63-41. After blowing a big lead in Game 1, Orlando now had to erase one.
O’Neal finished with 33 points, 12 rebounds and 7 assists on 12-of-22 shooting in 45 minutes. Hardaway had 32 points and 8 assists. Orlando took the third quarter 30-27 and the fourth 35-27, but it never got all the way back. Olajuwon had 34 points, 11 rebounds and 4 blocks on 14-of-30 shooting.
The surprise came off Houston’s bench. Sam Cassell scored 31 points on 8-of-12 shooting, hit 4 of 6 threes and went 11-of-12 at the line. Houston won 117-106, with Dan Crawford, Hue Hollins and Ed T. Rush officiating. The Magic were only the second team in Finals history to lose the first two games while holding home-court advantage.
Games 3 and 4 in Houston
The series moved to The Summit. Game 3, on June 11, drew 16,611 and stayed tight all night, with no quarter decided by more than three points. O’Neal scored 28. Olajuwon had 31 points, 14 rebounds and 7 assists in 45 minutes. Houston won 106-103 in the final moments, and Orlando was down 3-0.
Game 4 came on June 14. Olajuwon finished it with 35 points, 15 rebounds, 6 assists and 3 steals on 15-of-30 shooting in 44 minutes, and Houston won 113-101. He averaged 32.8 points, 11.5 rebounds and 5.5 assists for the series. O’Neal averaged 28.0 in the duel everyone had circled.
Olajuwon had help all series. Drexler averaged 21.5 points and 9.5 rebounds, and Horry averaged 17.8 points and 10.0 rebounds. When the Larry O’Brien Trophy was presented, Rudy Tomjanovich said, “Don’t ever underestimate the heart of a champion.” Orlando had spent four games learning exactly what he meant.
The 1995 Team, 21 Years Later
Houston became the lowest-seeded champion the league had seen to that point, and Olajuwon won his second straight Finals MVP. Orlando finished the postseason 11-10 over 21 games. None of its five starters had turned 30. The Magic were young, talented and one series short, beaten by a team that knew how to close.
The playoff numbers showed how much the core carried. O’Neal averaged 25.7 points and 11.9 rebounds, Hardaway 19.6 points and 7.7 assists, and Grant 13.7 points and 10.4 rebounds in 41.4 minutes. The group came back to win 60 games in 1995-96. Then O’Neal left Orlando.
Now, the Magic have two Finals appearances, 1995 and 2009, and no championship. They are coming off a 35-47 season. The 1995 team is where that history begins: two young stars, a champion at power forward and four June games that ended much sooner than anyone in Orlando expected.